A concern first raises a question of fact. Before it becomes an investigation, the purpose, legal basis and limits of the proposed measures also need to be established. This page explains German and EU law from the perspective of practical investigation work. It provides general information and does not replace individual legal advice or a privacy notice. The German statutes discussed here are not UK law, and the same rules cannot simply be assumed to apply in other countries.
What legal limits apply to private investigations?
What is the legal framework for private investigations in Germany?
Processing personal data for a private investigation requires a legal basis that supports the particular assignment. The information must serve a defined purpose and be limited to what is necessary for that purpose. The proposed measure must be assessed for necessity and for the proportionality of its interference with the rights of those affected. Employee information is subject to additional requirements, particularly where the aim is to investigate a possible criminal offence in the employment relationship. DETIX establishes and documents facts; legal advisers assess the law, and the court decides how material may be used in the proceedings before it.
Private investigators do not have general police powers. An instruction does not confer unrestricted access to someone else’s accounts or protected information, or a right to unlimited surveillance. The starting point is a defined question: which events need to be clarified, over what period, and what information is actually needed? An interest in another person’s private life does not justify every proposed measure.
Data protection: purpose limitation, data minimisation and accuracy
Article 5 of the GDPR sets principles for handling personal data. In an investigation, purpose limitation means that the agreed question defines the scope. Information gathered for a limited enquiry is not automatically available for unrelated purposes. Any proposed further use needs its own assessment.
Data minimisation affects both the choice of sources and what goes into the report. If a specific discrepancy in an expense claim needs explaining, the question is which information can explain it. That does not in itself justify collecting a person’s private contacts or daily habits. Information about uninvolved people encountered incidentally should not be included in the analysis without a relevant need.
Accuracy requires attention to shared names, outdated information and conflicting sources. A profile found online must be reliably attributable to the person concerned. In OSINT and digital research, the content of a source is therefore distinguished from a confirmed fact. Information does not become freely usable simply because it is publicly visible or searchable.
Appropriate protection includes limiting access to documents and the intended recipients, and agreeing how material will be transferred. Storage limitation requires retention to reflect the purpose and applicable obligations. It does not support keeping information indefinitely in case it becomes useful. Lawfulness, transparency and an accountable record of the processing also need to be considered.
What legal basis does the processing require?
Article 6 of the GDPR sets out different conditions for lawful processing. The applicable basis depends on the assignment, the people involved, the purpose and the nature of the information. A contract between a client and an investigation firm does not by itself authorise every use of information about a third party.
A party seeking to rely on legitimate interests must identify the particular interest, assess whether the processing is necessary, and balance it against the interests and fundamental rights of the person affected. The scope, the person’s expectations and the degree of intrusion matter. This is not a general authorisation for surveillance or open-source research.
Health information and other specially protected data, as well as information about criminal convictions or offences, require additional assessment. Transparency duties, individuals’ rights and any applicable statutory exceptions also need to be considered in the particular case. This page is not an exhaustive account of those requirements.
Optional further reading: GDPR, particularly Articles 5 and 6: consolidated text on EUR-Lex – external website, opens in a new tab.
Employee information and internal investigations
Section 26 of Germany’s Federal Data Protection Act, the BDSG, concerns processing for employment purposes. It also covers job applicants and former employees. The requirements depend on the purpose of the processing. A possible breach of an employment obligation is not automatically a criminal offence.
Section 26(1), second sentence, sets particular conditions for processing to detect criminal offences. Factual indications supporting suspicion against the person concerned in the employment relationship must be documented. The processing must be necessary to investigate the offence. The employee’s protected interest in excluding the processing must not override it, and the nature and extent of the processing must remain proportionate to the circumstances giving rise to it.
These conditions are not a checklist that automatically permits the use of investigators. Whether and how the provision supports a particular measure requires legal assessment alongside the GDPR and relevant case law. A sickness certificate, a discrepancy or an assumption does not by itself justify unrestricted covert monitoring. Applicable participation rights of employee representatives must also be respected.
For internal corporate investigations, the initial discussion therefore addresses the available facts, outstanding questions, less intrusive alternatives and the permitted scope with the responsible parties and, where appropriate, legal counsel. Exculpatory findings form part of the enquiry too.
Optional original source: Section 26 BDSG on Gesetze im Internet, in German – external website, opens in a new tab.
Surveillance and particularly intrusive measures
The more a measure interferes with privacy or data protection rights, the more carefully its factual basis, purpose, necessity and proportionality need to be assessed. Relevant factors include its duration, the area of life concerned, proposed recordings and effects on uninvolved people. A publicly accessible location does not remove these questions.
A measure must be suitable for the defined question. If an equally effective, less intrusive option is available, that matters to the assessment of necessity. Covert activity requires separate consideration; it is not an automatic part of every assignment. Changes in the facts may require the scope and continuation of the work to be reassessed. Our article on surveillance by a private investigator explains the practical planning.
Limits on photographs, video and audio recordings
A photograph or video is not permitted simply because it is technically possible or useful to the assignment. Section 201 of Germany’s Criminal Code, the StGB, protects non-public speech against unauthorised audio recording and certain other intrusions. A conversation may be non-public even in a publicly accessible place.
Section 201a StGB addresses specific infringements involving images, including recordings in protected spaces under the conditions set out in the provision, and other particularly protected situations. It is not a complete statement of every restriction on photographs and videos. Even outside its scope, data protection, privacy rights and other rules may restrict taking or sharing an image. Audio recording is not a standard component of a surveillance assignment.
Optional original sources: Section 201 StGB on Gesetze im Internet, in German – external website, opens in a new tab; Section 201a StGB on Gesetze im Internet, in German – external website, opens in a new tab.
Documenting findings and the court’s assessment of evidence
A report needs to show the basis for each statement. Direct observation records what an investigator perceived; technical documentation captures a particular view. A research finding comes from an identified source. Client information remains identifiable as information supplied by someone else, while assessments and hypotheses are distinguished from the facts supporting them. Our article on evidence documentation and investigation reports explains this in more detail.
Section 286 of Germany’s Code of Civil Procedure, the ZPO, concerns the court’s assessment of evidence in German civil proceedings. Within the statutory framework, the court decides whether it is satisfied that a factual assertion is true. The provision does not authorise information gathering or guarantee that privately obtained material may be used in proceedings. Careful documentation does not replace a separate legal assessment.
DETIX establishes facts and documents their source, timing, contradictions and limitations. Legal counsel assesses the law and the proposed use of the material in proceedings. The competent court decides in the particular case. Neither an investigation report nor certification guarantees admissibility. The German ZPO does not govern civil proceedings in other jurisdictions simply because DETIX prepared the report.
Optional original source: Section 286 ZPO on Gesetze im Internet, in German – external website, opens in a new tab.
Questions about the legal framework for private investigations
May a private investigation firm process personal data?
It may be lawful for a particular assignment if an appropriate legal basis and the other applicable requirements are satisfied. The purpose, scope of the information and affected rights need to be assessed. Publicly available information is not generally exempt from these requirements.
When can an employer ask investigators to examine a suspicion?
The available facts and proposed measures need legal assessment before the assignment begins. The grounds, necessity, less intrusive alternatives and proportionality matter. Section 26 BDSG sets particular requirements for investigating a possible criminal offence in the employment relationship.
Is an investigation report automatically admissible in court?
No. The circumstances in which information was obtained, the affected rights and the procedural rules require separate assessment. DETIX does not guarantee admissibility; the competent court decides in the particular proceedings.
Who decides whether an investigative measure is lawful?
The client and investigation provider must each comply with the duties that apply to them. Legally uncertain measures are assessed with qualified legal advisers before work starts; a client’s approval does not replace that assessment. A binding decision in a legal dispute is made by the competent court.
For a confidential enquiry to DETIX, please initially provide the reason for the enquiry, its objective and any deadlines. Send sensitive documents only through an agreed channel. Sources checked: 19 November 2026. The original sources offer optional detail on the German and EU legal framework explained here.
