Professional surveillance is not open-ended monitoring. It is a limited investigative measure designed to answer a specific factual question. Before work begins, the objective, starting position, legal basis, likely duration and documentation requirements must be defined. DETIX plans surveillance so that staffing and resources match the actual situation and so that observations can later be distinguished clearly from assumptions.
When can surveillance be appropriate?
Surveillance can be appropriate where a specific question can be answered by factual observation and less intrusive methods are unlikely to provide the necessary information. Typical contexts may include certain employee misconduct cases, unauthorised competitive activity, working-time or expense irregularities and clearly defined private or financial disputes.
General suspicion is not enough. The reason, objective, necessity and proportionality of the measure must be assessed before it begins.
Service page: https://detix.de/en/services/surveillance/
What information does a private investigator need before surveillance starts?
The most important elements are the factual question and reliable starting points. Depending on the assignment, useful information may include:
- the subject's name and a current photograph;
- a known address or other suitable starting location;
- vehicle details where lawfully available;
- known time windows, appointments or working hours;
- documented irregularities already identified;
- likely use of public transport or alternative routes;
- the precise fact that needs to be established;
- deadlines and an agreed cost framework.
A short factual description is normally sufficient for the initial assessment. Sensitive employee or health information should not be sent through insecure channels without prior agreement.
When is one investigator enough, and when are several needed?
There is no responsible rule stating that every surveillance assignment requires a fixed number of investigators. Staffing depends on the starting location, traffic conditions, possible exits, expected changes of transport, duration, operating area and the importance of maintaining continuity without becoming conspicuous.
Several investigators may be required where a location has multiple relevant exits, where movement between a vehicle and public transport is likely, or where repeated following by one vehicle would create an avoidable risk of detection. A simple and controlled situation may require fewer resources.
How are investigators and vehicles selected?
Resources are chosen for the actual operating environment rather than from a fixed package. Local knowledge, experience, expected duration, mobility and the need for unobtrusive handovers are important.
Where several investigators are involved, roles, communications, handovers and reporting lines should be agreed before deployment. Vehicles are selected to fit the environment and expected movement pattern.
How is a surveillance operation prepared?
Before deployment, the objective, starting point, time window, known movement information, legal limits, reporting requirements and cost framework are defined. Stop conditions and circumstances requiring reassessment are equally important.
A sound operational plan is not a rigid prediction. It defines the objective and boundaries while allowing lawful operational adjustments if the situation develops differently from what was expected.
How is surveillance conducted?
Investigators observe only within the agreed and lawful scope. Relevant events are recorded with time and place. Observation and interpretation are kept separate.
If the circumstances change materially, the team considers whether the operation should continue, be adjusted or be stopped. Losing sight of the subject does not justify an unlawful measure merely to preserve continuity.
How are observations documented?
A clear report records specific times, places and events that were actually observed. It should not claim to know what happened outside the surveillance period and should disclose material gaps in observation.
Photographs or video are considered only where they are lawful, necessary and relevant to the assignment. Non-public spoken conversations cannot simply be recorded secretly; Section 201 of the German Criminal Code imposes clear criminal-law restrictions.
What evidence can surveillance produce?
Surveillance can document factual observations: who was present at a particular place and time, what publicly observable conduct occurred, and which visible contacts took place. Where lawful, photographs or video may supplement the report. Investigators may also be able to testify to what they personally observed.
Observation does not automatically establish legal meaning. A meeting, for example, does not by itself prove a business arrangement or an intimate relationship. Legal assessment and admissibility in court depend on the individual case and are not guaranteed.
What legal limits apply?
Surveillance regularly engages privacy and data-protection rights. The applicable legal basis depends on the client, purpose, type of data and specific measure.
Employee cases require particular care. Section 26 of the German Federal Data Protection Act requires, among other things, documented factual indications, necessity and proportionality where employee data are processed to detect criminal conduct. Employment-law, collective-law and data-protection issues may also need to be assessed.
Images made in homes or other specially protected private spaces may also engage Section 201a of the German Criminal Code.
Further reading from DETIX: German legal framework for surveillance, employee data and audio/video recordings
Can an employer order surveillance where sick leave is suspected to be false?
A medical certificate of incapacity for work should not be challenged by surveillance merely because an employer has a general suspicion. In its judgment of 19 February 2015 – 8 AZR 1007/13 – the German Federal Labour Court held that surveillance, including covert video recording, was unlawful where there were no sufficiently substantiated reasons to doubt the certified incapacity.
The judgment is not a blanket authorisation for employee surveillance. The specific indications and the current legal position must be assessed before any measure is taken.
German judgment: German Federal Labour Court (BAG), 19 February 2015 – 8 AZR 1007/13 (judgment in German) – external website, opens in a new tab
When should surveillance be adjusted or stopped?
An operation should be reassessed where the starting assumptions change materially, the objective is no longer achievable, continued surveillance would become disproportionate, the subject can no longer reliably be observed, or a legal boundary is reached.
Cost and likely evidential value also matter. If the expected benefit no longer justifies continued expenditure, the client should receive a clear interim assessment before deciding whether to continue.
What does an operation with no relevant observation mean?
The absence of a relevant event is still a result for the period observed. It does not prove that the event did not occur at another time or place.
The report should therefore state the surveillance period, material gaps and the limits of what can properly be concluded.
What determines the cost of surveillance?
Cost is not determined by hours alone. Relevant factors include:
- number of investigators;
- number and type of vehicles;
- duration and time of day;
- travel distance;
- accommodation where required;
- handover and relief planning;
- reporting and documentation;
- cross-border or multi-location requirements.
A realistic operating plan and cost framework should be agreed before deployment. Understaffing can be operationally ineffective, while unnecessary staffing increases cost without adding value.
Can research be more appropriate before surveillance?
Not every question requires immediate surveillance. An unknown address, corporate link, vehicle association or digital connection may first be researched. Good preliminary research can improve starting points and reduce unnecessary surveillance time.
Corporate Investigations: https://detix.de/en/corporate-internal-fraud-investigations/
OSINT investigations: https://detix.de/en/osint-investigations/
Discuss a surveillance assignment confidentially
For an initial assessment, a concise factual question, the reason for the enquiry, known time windows and starting points, and any relevant deadline are sufficient.
Contact: https://detix.de/en/contact/
Reviewed by Peter Nalikowski
Owner, DETIX Investigations · self-employed private investigator since September 1992
Last reviewed: 19 November 2026
