Suspected Sick Pay Fraud – Assessment and Investigations

Do you have specific information suggesting that an employee may have falsely claimed to be unfit for work? DETIX can review the circumstances with you and discuss possible investigative steps. A sickness certificate, a general concern or a single leisure activity does not establish sick pay fraud. Before any measure is agreed, its purpose, factual basis and legal requirements must be assessed.

Discuss suspected sick pay fraud in Germany

Define the concern before commissioning work

Identify which statement conflicts with which verifiable fact. Separate your own observations, information from other people and assumptions. Record dates and the source of each relevant item. Unverified information should not be presented as established misconduct. The initial assessment must remain open to explanations that may clear the employee.

For an initial discussion, a short summary, the relevant period and the question you need answered are sufficient. Do not initially send complete personnel files, diagnoses or private messages. We will agree separately which records are needed and how they can be transferred.

Records that can help establish the facts

A dated first-hand account of specific work carried out during the reported absence may help HR identify a point to check. Once the scope is clear, HR or external counsel can prepare the relevant extracts.

  • A short timeline of the reported absence, the event in question and when the information reached the company.
  • The original source of the concern, such as a dated note of a direct observation or a link to a public source. For online material, distinguish the upload date from the date of the event it appears to show.
  • The relevant extract from the shift or work schedule and a brief description of the employee’s duties where those details bear on the specific question.
  • A note of checks already made and any less intrusive options considered, including an assessment through the German statutory health insurer where applicable.

Redact information unrelated to the question. We will agree which extracts are needed and how to send them after the initial enquiry.

When surveillance may be considered

The assignment, permitted methods and necessary scope must be agreed with the responsible parties before work begins. Processing employee data requires a suitable legal basis and an assessment of necessity and proportionality. An investigation agency does not replace your legal department or the legal assessment of an individual case.

Before commissioning surveillance, identify the question to be answered, the legal basis for processing, any suitable less intrusive alternatives and whether the measure would be proportionate. Use a less intrusive measure if it can answer the question. This applies even to activity visible from a public place. Documenting a person’s observable state of health constitutes processing of health data. That processing also requires an exception to the general prohibition under Article 9 GDPR. In an employment context, the assessment must address any applicable basis under Article 9(2)(b) GDPR and section 26(3) of the German Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG), together with appropriate safeguards under section 22(2) BDSG.

In the case before the German Federal Labour Court, surveillance was not necessary. The medical certificates of incapacity for work retained their evidential value. For this type of case, the Court identified two necessary conditions for processing health data through surveillance. There must be specific facts sufficient to undermine the evidential value of the certificate, and a less intrusive assessment by the Medical Service must be unavailable or objectively unlikely to resolve the issue. Where section 275(1a) of Book V of the German Social Code applies, the employer may ask the statutory health insurer to obtain an assessment from the Medical Service. German Federal Labour Court, 25 July 2024, 8 AZR 225/23, paras. 18–30 – external website, opens in a new tab · Book V of the German Social Code, section 275(1a) – external website, opens in a new tab

Whether surveillance is lawful still depends on the circumstances. Agree the time frame, scope and limits on what may be recorded before any work begins. Collect only the information needed for the agreed question. End surveillance once that question is resolved or the factual grounds for the measure no longer exist.

Our surveillance service page explains how fieldwork is carried out. If the case involves several allegations, locations or business units, see our coordinated internal investigations.

Agree the scope and budget

We discuss which facts are missing, which information is lawfully available and what a further measure could actually establish. The scope, timeframes, budget and reporting arrangements are then agreed. Work should not silently expand to additional days, locations or individuals. Before an assignment begins, we clarify who can authorise further steps.

What an investigation report can establish

The report describes the events established and explains the limitations of the findings. An observed activity is not a medical diagnosis and does not by itself establish whether someone could perform their particular job. Findings, unverified information and unanswered questions are separated. Results that do not support the original concern also belong in an objective account. Decisions about employment consequences and the use of particular findings remain with the responsible parties.

A report your legal team can review

A report can open with the question asked and the period covered. Each material entry in the timeline identifies its source. The findings distinguish confirmed facts, explanations supported by the records and points that could not be verified. The annex can list the supporting records and where they came from. If a source confirms only the date of publication, the report records that limit.

Fictional example · A recording appears during sickness absence

During an employee’s sickness absence, an event organiser uploads a recording of a talk given by that employee. HR asks whether the talk itself took place during the reported absence.

In this fictional example, the organiser labels the video as a replay of an earlier event. The event programme lists the talk, and the host identifies the event date in the recording. Both put the talk before the absence. The publication date falls within the absence period, but the material does not support the allegation that the employee gave the talk during that period.

The records do not support the specific concern. The timing question is resolved without surveillance. The report records the sequence of events and leaves medical assessment outside its scope.

Questions about suspected sick pay fraud

Are frequent periods of sickness absence enough to commission surveillance?

Frequency alone does not define a specific investigation. Explain the actual inconsistencies and where the information came from. Whether they support a lawful measure requires a separate assessment.

Does every enquiry lead to surveillance?

No. The initial assessment may show that information is missing, that another means of clarification should be used or that a measure is not appropriate. Surveillance is not agreed simply because it has been requested.

Can investigation costs be recovered?

Recovery is not automatic. The basis, necessity, scope and results of the investigation may be relevant. Ask your legal advisers to assess any claim in the individual case. DETIX does not promise that its costs will be recoverable.

Can our law firm coordinate the assignment?

Yes. We can agree the factual questions, report format and follow-up enquiries with the instructed law firm. See our Investigations for lawyers.

Discuss the concern in confidence

DETIX is based in Dieburg near Darmstadt and handles enquiries relating to Germany. Please tell us what prompted the concern, the relevant period and how to contact you in confidence. We will arrange the secure transfer of any supporting records separately.

Send a confidential initial enquiry

Legal references checked on 9 November 2026: Section 26 BDSG and the legal framework in Germany, BAG 8 AZR 225/23 and BAG 8 AZR 1026/12 – external website, opens in a new tab. The specific legal assessment is carried out on a case-by-case basis.