Time entries repeatedly conflict with records of work performed. A cost appears in two expense claims. A travel claim cannot be linked to a business appointment. DETIX helps employers, HR and compliance teams, and legal counsel work out which discrepancies can be established and what the records can explain.
Checking time entries against work records
Timesheets, rosters and job records serve different purposes. Before comparing them, we establish what each record shows and how corrections are made. An entry in a timekeeping system may record hours claimed, whereas a job sheet may confirm completion without stating how long the task took.
For a defined period, we can compare time entries with rosters, job sheets, records of work performed and documented approvals that can be shared lawfully. We consider amendments, differences in recording practices, travel time and authorised work away from site. Concerns involving sickness absence raise separate privacy issues, including possible processing of health data. See investigations into suspected sick pay fraud for that distinct issue under German law.
Reconciling expense claims with supporting records
We compare each relevant claim with receipts, travel dates, approvals and the company policy in force at the time. The review can identify possible duplicate reimbursements, inconsistent dates or a cost for which the records give no clear business purpose. A refund, cancellation or corrected submission may explain what initially looks like a duplicate.
The findings distinguish between claims that can be reconciled and entries that remain unsupported. Where the disputed invoice or performance record belongs to an external supplier, our procurement and supplier fraud investigations page describes the relevant review.
Choosing proportionate investigative steps
We agree the question, relevant records and time period first. Depending on the case, the work may involve a targeted document comparison, source checks or agreed follow-up questions. We consider surveillance only where a specific question remains and less intrusive measures cannot answer it as effectively. Its lawfulness must be assessed for the particular case.
For matters subject to German and EU law, processing employee data requires an applicable legal basis under the GDPR and must comply with principles including purpose limitation and data minimisation. Where section 26(1), second sentence, of Germany’s Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG) is relied on, its text requires documented facts that give grounds to suspect the person concerned of an offence in the employment context. The processing must be necessary for investigating that offence and proportionate, and the person’s interest in excluding the processing must not outweigh the employer’s interest. Whether it provides a legal basis in the particular case must be assessed alongside the GDPR. An unexplained entry, on its own, establishes neither dishonesty nor a criminal offence.
Intrusive measures need a separate, case-specific assessment. In Germany, the introduction or use of technical equipment to monitor behaviour or performance is subject to the works council’s co-determination rights under section 87(1), no. 6, of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) where the statutory conditions are met. The employer should settle the legal position and any participation requirements with counsel where needed before authorising such a step. See internal corporate investigations for matters that involve several functions within the organisation.
Preserving records and reporting the findings
We identify the source, date and version of the records reviewed and link each comparison to the entry it concerns. Where possible and lawful, supplied originals are kept intact. Copies, extracts and amended records are identified separately. Access and retention are limited in line with the agreed purpose and applicable requirements.
Where lawful on-site investigations form part of an assignment, we record relevant observations, timelines and identified discrepancies in a clear and traceable manner. The focus is on determining whether specific suspicions can be examined against actual observations. Our findings are consolidated into a structured investigation report, enabling the client to assess the established facts on an informed basis.
The report records the scope, sources, periods reviewed, findings and alternative explanations supported by the material. It identifies gaps and distinguishes what the records establish from what remains an inference. The employer and its advisers determine the employment implications. A court’s decision on whether evidence can be used is a separate matter. Our investigative support for law firms can be scoped around the factual questions counsel needs answered.
Questions before instructing DETIX
What should we send at the outset?
Start with a description of the discrepancy, the relevant period, the types of records held and any deadline. Mention any documented correction. Please agree a suitable method with us before sending files that contain employee data.
Can the review end with the records already available?
Yes. A review may establish an ordinary explanation or show that further enquiries are unlikely to resolve the question. Findings that weaken the suspicion and points that remain open are recorded alongside any confirmed discrepancy.
Discuss a time or expense discrepancy in confidence
Tell us which record is in question and what decision the review needs to inform. We can agree an initial step and identify the material needed for it.
German and EU legal sources
- EU GDPR · EUR-Lex, Articles 5 and 6, and Article 9 for health data – external website, opens in a new tab
- DETIX legal framework: data protection and employee data in Germany
- Section 87(1), no. 6, German Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), on Gesetze im Internet (in German) – external website, opens in a new tab
- German Federal Labour Court (BAG), 27 July 2017 – 2 AZR 681/16 (judgment in German) – external website, opens in a new tab
- German Federal Labour Court (BAG), 25 July 2024 – 8 AZR 225/23 (judgment in German) – external website, opens in a new tab
- German Federal Labour Court (BAG), 29 June 2023 – 2 AZR 296/22 (judgment in German) – external website, opens in a new tab
